It’s a strange and often overlooked rule, one that can turn the tide of a baseball game in an instant. A slight tick of the bat against the catcher’s mitt, and suddenly a routine out becomes a runner on first base. Catcher’s interference, once a rarity, is becoming an increasingly common and pivotal part of Major League Baseball, forcing players and managers to pay closer attention to the subtle interactions at home plate.
MLB’s Obscure Rule Takes Center Stage
At its core, catcher’s interference is designed to protect a batter’s right to swing without impediment. According to the Official Baseball Rules, if a catcher’s glove makes contact with the bat during a swing, the batter is awarded first base. The umpire typically signals the infraction but allows the play to continue.
This gives the offensive team’s manager a choice: accept the penalty and send the batter to first, or take the result of the play if it’s more advantageous, like a home run. If the penalty is accepted, the catcher is charged with an error, and the batter is not charged with an at-bat.
For decades, this was a minor footnote in the rulebook. For 50 years, MLB averaged around 20 interference calls per season. That number has exploded recently, reaching a record 97 instances in 2023, up from just nine in 2002. One of the primary drivers is the modern emphasis on pitch framing. Advanced metrics reward catchers who can “steal” strikes by receiving the ball closer to the plate, a strategy that inherently increases the risk of their glove getting in the way.
The introduction of instant replay has also played a significant role. In 2023, managers challenged 64 plays where interference was not initially called, and an astounding 70% of those were overturned, adding calls that umpires had missed. Some players also seem to have a knack for drawing the call.
MORE: Former MLB GM Reveals What’s Next for Giants After ‘Winning Trade Deadline’ With Rafael Devers Trade
We witnessed the most recent example of this rule during the 10th inning at Citizens Bank Park in Philadelphia, where the Phillies were taking on the Boston Red Sox.
With the game tied 2-2 in the bottom of the 10th inning, Red Sox reliever Kenley Jansen took the mound. The situation quickly unraveled. Jansen walked the leadoff batter, and a subsequent wild pitch advanced runners to second and third. An intentional walk then loaded the bases with no outs, bringing Edmundo Sosa to the plate.
BASEBALL IS AMAZING! pic.twitter.com/DejHWQJpFA
— Philadelphia Phillies (@Phillies) July 22, 2025
On a 1-2 count, Sosa offered a checked swing, but his bat clipped the glove of Red Sox catcher Connor Wong. The umpire immediately signaled catcher’s interference, forcing in the winning run from third for a bizarre walk-off Phillies victory.
This peculiar infraction sits at the intersection of strategy, skill, and the ever-present potential for human error. While it may seem like a minor rule, its increasing frequency has made it a significant factor in today’s game. It serves as a constant reminder that in baseball, a game of inches, even the slightest touch can change everything.