Cleveland Browns fans didn’t wait for the season to start before picking favorites. One preseason outing, and the Browns’ fifth-round draft pick has already got fans buzzing. Joe Flacco is the expected starter, but Northern Ohio has a soft spot for the rookie who came under the microscope before, during, and after the NFL Draft. Add a backup battle with Dillon Gabriel to the mix, and now every snap, tweet, and mistake is under the fan microscope, especially when it adds fuel to the quarterback competition fire.
How Will Dillon Gabriel’s Pick-Six Against the Eagles Affect the Quarterback Battle?
Things went sideways for Gabriel early in the second quarter during the Browns’ preseason showdown with the Philadelphia Eagles. Gabriel rolled out to his left, looking for a quick throw, but Eagles defensive back Andrew Mukuba stepped in front, picked it off, and took it all the way to the house for a pick-six.
Andrew Mukuba PICK-6!
The @Eagles second-round pick takes Dillon Gabriel’s pass to the house.
Watch on @NFLNetwork
Stream on @NFLPlus pic.twitter.com/n5jsRGN4Bw
— NFL (@NFL) August 16, 2025
Right after the play, fans immediately threw their support behind Sanders. One, looking to highlight how Gabriel’s mistake gave Sanders a PR boost, chimed in with, “perfect timingg.”
perfect timingg https://t.co/GQ4iZYkj4W pic.twitter.com/p9uWGDKYQ4
— AI: JR (@shmunkysr) August 16, 2025
Someone else asked a question that’s on a lot of people’s minds, “where was he throwing?” Fan reactions piled up fast.
Where was he throwing ?? https://t.co/AjzNNCfDaP
— َ (@itsBKTyy) August 16, 2025
The memes and jokes kept coming. One fan posted a fake Nike ad with the caption, “Only a matter of time.”
https://t.co/q2loUAU87o pic.twitter.com/KNGIO0Y3HD
— gotti (@bdbgotti) August 16, 2025
One more declared, “Shedeur FC never loses,” adding a bit of team loyalty to the moment.
Shedeur FC never loses https://t.co/lgBDdTWy7J
— John 🇨🇻 (@YaBoyyyJohn) August 16, 2025
Someone compared Gabriel’s pass to fast food, posting, “Threw a chicken fry from Burger King.”
Threw a chicken fry from Burger King https://t.co/HW2ZdnBo8T
— oinkfish (@OinkFish_Pigs) August 16, 2025
Others didn’t hold back either. One poster shared his excitement with, “Dillon Gabriel pick 6 is food for my SOUL.”
Dillon Gabriel pick 6 is food for my SOUL. https://t.co/7WkHVI1fpW pic.twitter.com/DgqoZ7daJq
— JT (@Jteeeeeezy) August 16, 2025
One fan threw out a strong take that Gabriel’s pick-six “just ruined Dillon Gabriel’s entire career … This is now officially who he is.”
I don’t wanna overreact, but that pick 6 just ruined Dillon Gabriel’s entire career
😂😂😂😂😂
This is now officially who he is
— Mike (@NinerTribe004) August 16, 2025
Another mocked the QB debate with, “Dillon Gabriel just threw a pick 6, and yall think he better than Sanders … yall don’t know ball.”
Dillon Gabriel just threw a pick 6, and yall think he better than Sanders 😂😂 yall don’t know ball
— C O V (@CamCovvv) August 16, 2025
The jokes weren’t stopping. A Shedeur Sanders fan joined in, posting, “DILLON GABRIEL HATEWATCH GOING GREAT.”
DILLON GABRIEL HATEWATCH GOING GREAT 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 pic.twitter.com/lkD6IlGLch
— smaller 🐍 (@smalleruzivert) August 16, 2025
And finally, a fan put it bluntly: “Dillon Gabriel your career is over as a starting quarterback just like that.”
Dillon Gabriel your career is over as a starting quarterback just like that https://t.co/uugIeAOL8v
— 200 💿 (@a3roadnax) August 16, 2025
Looking at the big picture, both Gabriel and Sanders are still chasing Joe Flacco, who holds down the top spot for the Browns right now. Still, Gabriel’s mistake definitely doesn’t help his fight for the job, especially while Sanders is dealing with an oblique injury that’s keeping him on the sideline. For Cleveland fans, every preseason snap just got a whole lot more interesting.