Rob Manfred finds himself in the crosshairs again, accused of using the Los Angeles Dodgers’ massive spending and 2024 World Series Championship as ammunition for his salary cap agenda. But the players’ union isn’t buying it. They’re calling out what they see as a calculated move to weaponize the Dodgers’ success against the very concept of competitive balance that baseball has achieved.
Why Is the MLBPA Pushing Back Against Manfred’s Salary Cap Push?
Every offseason brings the same tired debate about whether the Dodgers’ payroll and deferred contracts create an unfair advantage. For fans in smaller markets, a salary cap seems like the obvious fix to level the playing field. That narrative conveniently aligns with what Manfred and the league officials have been pushing for years.
However, MLBPA’s deputy executive director, Bruce Meyer, has none of it. Speaking on a segment with Foul Territory, Meyer shot down the idea that baseball needs a salary cap to maintain competitive balance. His reasoning cuts straight to the heart of the matter: parity already exists for teams that intelligently build and invest in their rosters.
“When you look at MLB’s recent history, especially compared to other sports, small-market teams have absolutely found success,” Meyer explained. “Since the Mets last won a World Series, teams like Minnesota, Kansas City, Cincinnati, and Tampa Bay have either won it all or been consistently competitive.”
Meyer’s argument gains strength when you consider the track record of baseball’s biggest spenders. Even with their massive payrolls, teams like the Dodgers and New York Yankees aren’t guaranteed championships the way critics claim they should be.
“The Mets haven’t won in 40 years, the Dodgers have just two titles in nearly four decades, and the Yankees haven’t won in 15,” Meyer pointed out.
It almost feels like the league is weaponizing the Dodgers to help push for a salary cap, says @MLBPA Deputy Executive Director Bruce Meyer.
“In the last 25 years, the team with the top payroll has won the World Series four times.” pic.twitter.com/E8EPJJoENu
— Foul Territory (@FoulTerritoryTV) July 8, 2025
The evidence supporting Meyer’s position extends beyond just the big-market failures. Smaller-market clubs like the Cardinals and Rays have built sustainable success through smart roster construction and player development. Even more telling, Meyer pointed to the Detroit Tigers in 2025, who currently hold the league’s best record despite not being among baseball’s biggest spenders.
What Does the Recent World Series History Tell Us About Payroll and Success?
Meyer didn’t stop at pointing out the failures of high-spending teams. He also highlighted the 2023 World Series between the Arizona Diamondbacks and Texas Rangers as concrete proof that parity exists and that Manfred’s narrative doesn’t hold water.
“In the last 25 years, the team with the top payroll has won the World Series just four times,” Meyer stated. “Just last year, we had Arizona and Texas in the [2023] World Series. Arizona had the eighth-highest payroll, Texas was 18th.”
This statistic demolishes the idea that massive spending guarantees postseason success. Meyer emphasized that the expanded playoff format has only strengthened this competitive balance, allowing teams at all payroll levels to compete for championships.
The union representative didn’t mince words when addressing what he sees as Manfred’s opportunistic approach to the salary cap debate. Meyer pushed back against the agenda being driven by league officials, suggesting using the Dodgers as a scapegoat was convenient.
“It feels like the league is weaponizing the fact that the Dodgers won and signed some stars,” he said. “But a lot of those players were available to anyone.”
This perspective highlights a crucial point often overlooked in salary cap discussions: the Dodgers’ success isn’t just about outspending everyone else. It’s about making smart decisions with their resources and building a sustainable, winning culture.
The timing of this debate becomes even more significant with the current MLB Collective Bargaining Agreement set to expire at the end of 2026. The salary cap debate continues to be a substantial point of contention between the MLBPA and league officials led by Manfred.
If the two sides can’t resolve this and other key issues, baseball could face another lockout and potential work stoppage ahead of the 2027 season. The stakes couldn’t be higher, and Meyer’s comments suggest the players’ union is prepared to fight against what they see as an unnecessary restriction on player compensation.
MORE: Rob Manfred’s Most Ambitious MLB Vision Gains Momentum After Rays’ $1,700,000,000 Twist and A’s Vegas Breakthrough