Bryce Underwood walked into Ann Arbor with a $12 million NIL deal and the weight of being college football’s top recruit. Fans call him the “best freshman in the country” before he’s even taken a snap.
But with that kind of money and hype comes a question that’s splitting college football: Is he worth it, or is everyone getting ahead of themselves?
Why Did Bryce Underwood Choose Michigan Over LSU?
The former LSU commit shocked the college football world on November 21, 2024, when he flipped to Michigan after nearly a year of pledging to the Tigers. The same day, he signed with the Wolverines, shifting the momentum of Sherrone Moore’s first season in Ann Arbor.
That decision, widely discussed across recruiting circles, also reinforced Michigan’s growing reputation in the NIL space. Underwood’s reported agreement with the university is believed to be worth between $10.5 million and $12 million over four years, making him one of the highest-valued recruits in college football history.
Who do you think will be the best Freshman in the country next year 💬? pic.twitter.com/HslJd476xO
— College Football Report (@CFBRep) July 11, 2025
When College Football Report asked fans on X who they believed would be the top freshman in the country next season, responses poured in.
“Underwood and it’s not close,” one user wrote.
Another pointed out: “The True Freshman Running Back at Clemson is going to have a big year,”
“As a Michigan fan I hope it’s Bryce,” a fan remarked.
As a Michigan fan I hope it’s Bryce
— Mr6foot2 (@Marques_J_Smith) July 12, 2025
“Bryce Underwood might be the best player period,” another remarked.
What Makes Underwood’s Arrival at Michigan So Historic?
His arrival makes him the second No. 1 overall prospect to sign with Michigan in the modern recruiting rankings era, joining Rashan Gary (2016). He also joins a short list of elite prospects to pick the Wolverines, including Jabrill Peppers (No. 3 in 2014), Ryan Mallett (No. 5 in 2007), LaMarr Woodley (No. 4 in 2003), and Prescott Burgess (No. 5 in 2003).
Underwood’s high school resume was dominant. Over four seasons, he threw for 11,488 yards. He accounted for 179 total touchdowns with 27 rushing TDs and 152 passing TDs, winning two state championships and compiling a 50-4 record. His national spotlight grew even brighter when he became the No. 1 recruit before his junior year.
Read More: Analyst Predicts ‘Samurai Sword’ QB Bryce Underwood Could Turn Michigan into 2025’s Biggest Sleeper
Despite his accolades, Underwood’s youth and inexperience leave questions unanswered. He won’t turn 18 until August 19, 2025, just before Michigan’s opener against New Mexico. He enters a quarterback battle that features Fresno State transfer Mikey Keene and second-year player Jadyn Davis.
At 6’4″ and 208 pounds, Underwood possesses elite physical traits, including a powerful arm and the mobility to escape pressure and create big plays. Against weaker opponents like Central Michigan, his natural tools alone could give Michigan a decisive edge. However, how well he transitions to the college level remains uncertain, even as expectations soar.